Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.
“I use Simms Mattingly for both my auto insurance and now my (first) home insurance. I could not recommend this team enough. When purchasing my first home, there was some uncertainty about the age of the HVAC unit on the property (which could’ve affected the ability to insure the home). Instead of me getting seller permission/finding an HVAC tech/scheduling & paying out of pocket for the HVAC tech to come verify the age of the unit, Simms Mattingly sent one of their team members out to the property for me that same day. They got the age of the unit and had my home insurance paperwork done that evening! They go the extra mile!!”
“Excellent service and products!!! What else can we say? Alice Galbraith is always reachable and goes above and beyond taking care of our insurance needs. Situations that would usually take days with our previous insurance companies, Alice takes care of immediately! Thank you, Alice and Erie Insurance for employing her!!”
“My husband and I have been a customer for over 30 years with Simms Mattingly Insurance (previously known as Mattingly Insurance) for our homeowners, vehicle, and life insurance needs! I have referred friends and family as they are consistently personal, professional, efficient, and will take the necessary amount of time needed to handle all of your needs whether it is for a new price quote, adding drivers, handling a claim, or helping with payment options. I have never ever encountered any problems and I highly recommend Simms Mattingly Insurance Agency!”
“My experience with Simms Mattingly Insurance Agency has been nothing short of stellar! Julie Slater is patient, helpful, and quick to respond. For example, we looked at numerous vehicles when getting ready to purchase the past two. I sent Julie several VINs for her to quote prices for insurance. This was quite helpful to us in making a purchase decision. She has always been pleasant to work with and answers questions quickly, accurately, and cheerfully. Each time we purchased a vehicle, she was able to quickly get the new policy added with minimal effort on our part. If you are looking for a vehicle or house insurance, see Julie at Simms Mattingly Insurance Agency. She will find just the policy you need at a price that other agencies were unable to match during my searches. I am so glad I was directed to Simms Mattingly! ”
“I highly recommend Simms-Mattingly Insurance. I’ve been with them for over 20yrs. Alice (my insurance agent) is the most helpful agent I have ever dealt with. She is honest and upfront with everything. She does a fantastic job finding the right coverage and insurance at a very competitive price. I’m definitely happy and will always be a loyal customer.”