Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.
- GSHandling your finances is stressful enough. Even more so when you have to worry...Greg S., Lexington Park, Maryland
“Handling your finances is stressful enough. Even more so when you have to worry about your car, your new house, and your insurance policies. Especially when you are about to move into that new house. Sure enough, Simms Insurance Agency (SIA) is willing to walk alongside you every step of the way.
As you try to sort everything out, the staff are ready to guide or educate you through your uncertainties. The staff are compassionate, informative, and maintain constant, casual professionalism. Scheduling is easy-going, prioritizing your time first. Communication responses are always diligent with warm same-day responses. In short, the staff of SIA make you feel valued as a client and a person.
Simms Insurance Agency proves a competent, reliable competitor to other insurance agencies. Unafraid of service comparisons, SIA encourages personal education and choice. Do a little research. You will find SIA’s coverage and rates are more than competitive. They remain ever flexible to the constant changes introduced in your life. When you are dealing with a crisis, Simms Insurance Agency will be there for you.”
- DN...very knowledgeable, courteous and professional.
“I honestly have been very pleased every time I have ever had a question concerning a claim and/or something referencing my coverage. Everyone in your office is very knowledgeable, courteous and professional. I believe I have been one of your customers for nearly 40 years, if not longer. I will continue to be your customer for many more years.”
- MG...always looking to help us save money
“I’ve worked with Alice for over 25 years. She is always looking to help us save money by researching our options. Mattingly Insurance & Alice are always courteous and responsive.”
- TGVery professional and very courteous people.
“We have been with Mattingly Insurance for over 30 years now. We have only had to make a few claims in all that time. Once for the home from a lightning strike and a couple times for Auto issues. Each time it was a piece of cake working with them to get our issues taken care of. Very professional and very courteous people. They never mind answering questions or helping out in any way needed. We will remain with Erie Ins. Co. and Mattingly Insurance Agency as long as their doors are open.”
- LSWe would highly recommend Mattingly Insurance Agency.
“The entire staff has always been friendly and helpful. Our agent Julie has always been quick to assist with adding our toys (RV) to providing proof of insurance at a moments notice. We would highly recommend Mattingly Insurance Agency.”
- JMWe love the personal attention...Jeffery M., Lexington Park, Maryland
“We love the personal attention we get from you guys at Simms. Its not like the companies you call and get transferred several times before you speak to a person. Thanks keep up the great work.”
- JHWell, it's like this: If you were a restaurant and served up a meal that IAnonymous, La plata, MDCustomer since Jul 2004
“Well, it’s like this: If you were a restaurant and served up a meal that I didn’t like, I’d quickly find another place to eat. We stuck with you (for a long time) because you have always been there when we needed to submit a claim…. and treated us like we are “friends” and not just another guy off the street. Keep up the good work…..”
- DHEverything. Filing this claim was a very seamless process. ThankAnonymous, Leonardtown, MDCustomer since Jul 1998
“Everything. Filing this claim was a very seamless process. Thank you”
- RSsimms agency always takes care of me when i have changes or questions answered.Lexington Park, MDCustomer since Jun 2002
“simms agency always takes care of me when i have changes or questions answered. That’s why iv’e been a customer for 17 years. thanks”
- RLYOUR iNSURANCE PRICES FOR MY VEHICLES ARE VERY MUCH IN LINE AND IT IS NICEAnonymous, Avenue, MDCustomer since May 2007
“YOUR iNSURANCE PRICES FOR MY VEHICLES ARE VERY MUCH IN LINE AND IT IS NICE WHEN I NEED TO TALK TO A REPRESENTATIVE THE RESPONSE IS PROMINENT”
- Jacob V., Mechanicsville, Maryland
“Sandy and her team have taken great care of me for many years. They recently supported me through a claim and were amazing! Their team was extremely quick to respond and guided me through every step of the way. The entire process was smooth from start to finish, and their communication skills ensured I was always taken care of and kept up to date. I can’t thank them enough!”
- WGWilliam G., Lexington Park, Maryland
“Laurie Terracciano is incredibly knowledgeable and easy to work with. She answered all of my questions promptly and in their entirety, and explained things in a way that I could easily understand. Thanks to Laurie, she made the process of signing up for home and auto insurance straight forward and stress free. My experience has been excellent.”
- Hailey G., Mechanicsville, Maryland
“The erie team has never failed my family and I. Julie Slater is our main point of contact for all auto insurance needs and she goes above and beyond every time. She is effective and efficient, and always refers us to qualified associates.”
- Aaron O., Lexington Park, Maryland
“Sandy Dorsey and her team are skilled, responsive, and truly look out for their clients. They take the time to make sure you understand your options and get what fits you best. You can tell they care about the people they serve.”
- MCMatthew C., Mechanicsville, Maryland
“I worked with Rebecca Fox to get a quote for a home and auto insurance bundle. She was able to get me a quote, answer all my questions and get me signed up within a day, saving me over $150/month. I highly recommend her if you are looking for insurance!”



